← Back
The Broken Ring: This Marriage Will Fail Anyway cover
9.2OUR SCORE
ManhwaHiatus · 127+ chR15 · our rating

The Broken Ring: This Marriage Will Fail Anyway

이 결혼은 어차피 망하게 되어 있다 · This Marriage Is Bound to Sink Anyway · This Marriage Is Bound to Fail Anyway

by CHACHA KIM; CHOKAM · DCCENT; KakaoPage; Tappytoon · 2022

best for mature historical romance with regression, marriage-first devotion, a deeply traumatized heroine, political family pressure, and a male lead who grows from careless fiancé to steadfast husband

Story9.1Art9.4Romance9.0
Read on Tappytoon

Also on: Tappytoon Novel · Tappytoon Steamy Edition · KakaoPage

Heads-up: abuse and grief / loss, and more. All content notes

Ch. 01 · The story

What it's about

Spoiler level: Moderate — for the synopsis & review below

At six years old, Inés Valeztena selects the handsome Cárcel Escalante as her fiancé. Cárcel spends the next fifteen years resisting the match and living as a notorious playboy, unaware that Inés welcomes his behavior because she intends to use it to end their future marriage. Her cold plan hides memories of ruined past lives and a desperate wish for freedom. Once Cárcel realizes she truly expects nothing from him, he becomes determined to prove he can be the husband she never believed she could have.

Ch. 02 · Our verdict

My take

This looks like a witty engagement-of-convenience story at first, then steadily reveals a far darker portrait of trauma, fate, and survival. Inés is fascinating because her detachment is strategy rather than indifference, and Cárcel's transformation into a perceptive, devoted partner gives the romance real emotional weight. The lavish art and adult chemistry are excellent, though the nonlinear revelations demand patience and close reading.

— coff33latt33

✓ Read it if…

The story rewards readers who enjoy psychologically layered heroines and romances that change meaning as hidden history surfaces. Inés and Cárcel have sharp chemistry, the marriage becomes unexpectedly tender, and the art makes every expression, uniform, and period setting feel luxurious.

! Skip it if…

Infidelity dominates the premise, and Inés's past contains sexual violence, pregnancy loss, abuse, and severe emotional trauma. The chronology can be confusing before her earlier lives are explained, while the dense internal monologues and slow political sections may frustrate readers seeking a lighter romance.

Ch. 03 · The vibe

Story profile

Story profile
Pacing: Slow-burn
How it feels
Romance focusIntense
Romantic tensionIntense
AngstIntense
ComedyA little
ActionA little
Plot complexityIntense
💞 Romance dynamic
Who falls firstMale lead
Couple dynamicPush & pull
Power balanceIt shifts
Romance speedSlow-burn
✓ Story strengths
Earned character growthBelievable motivationsConsequences matterGorgeous artStrong visual storytelling
⚠ Story frustrations
Long flashbacks
From my reading notes— coff33latt33

How it uses its tropes

I like how becoming a better husband can make Cárcel a bigger problem for Inés. She chose this engagement with an exit in mind, so his growing commitment interferes with the future she planned. It gives the marriage-first setup an uncomfortable question: what happens when the relationship improving is exactly what one person was trying to avoid?

A fresh start in a familiar place

I find Calztela an especially uneasy setting for their newlywed life. A coastal home might suggest a fresh start, but Inés arrives with memories that prevent it from being one. That contrast makes the setting matter to me: sharing a new home doesn’t mean they’re entering it with the same sense of possibility.

Serious Content Warnings
AbuseGrief / LossPhysical AbuseSexual ViolenceSuicide
Content Notes
BloodDomestic AbuseEmotional AbuseInfertilityMental Illness ThemesMiscarriagePregnancy LossPsychological AbuseSexual AssaultViolence
Ch. 04 · Next up

If you liked this

Install Moonlight Toons: tap Share then Add to Home Screen.